Blog

WooCommerce Subscriptions vs. Native Renewals: What to Use When

/ by Ava Taylor

Running an online store is already a challenge, so when it comes to subscriptions and renewals, the last thing you need is more confusion. You’ve probably heard about WooCommerce Subscriptions and Native WooCommerce Renewals. But which one should you use? And when?

Let’s break it down in simple terms. We’ll look at the key differences, pros and cons, and when each option makes the most sense for your store.

What’s the Deal With WooCommerce Subscriptions?

WooCommerce Subscriptions is a paid plugin that adds powerful subscription features to your WooCommerce store. With it, you can sell weekly yoga classes, monthly coffee boxes, or annual software licenses!

Here’s what it lets you do:

  • Set up billing intervals (daily, weekly, monthly, yearly)
  • Offer free trials and signup fees
  • Pause, resume, and cancel subscriptions
  • Let customers manage billing and shipping dates
  • Support for manual and automatic renewals

Sounds great, right? Well, it is—especially if you want maximum flexibility and full control.

Pros of WooCommerce Subscriptions:

  • Lots of customization for your subscription products
  • Automatic renewals with payment gateways like Stripe and PayPal
  • Trial periods and custom billing schedules
  • Email reminders for upcoming bills or failed payments

Cons:

  • Not free. It’s a premium plugin with an annual license cost
  • Requires more setup time and testing
  • Can be overwhelming if you’re just starting out

What Are Native WooCommerce Renewals?

WooCommerce now includes limited subscription capabilities through the core checkout and payment tools. These are called Native WooCommerce Renewals. It’s basically using built-in tools and the native Stripe Gateway to manage recurring payments—but with fewer bells and whistles.

Think of it as a more basic way to offer repeat billing. It’s great for keeping things simple.

Pros of Native Renewals:

  • No extra plugin costs if you already have Stripe or supported gateways
  • Simple setup—no need to configure complex options
  • Good choice for beginners or stores with basic recurring needs

Cons:

  • Not as flexible. You can’t do fixed-length trials or signup fees
  • No email customizations specific to subscriptions
  • Fewer control options for the customer

When to Use WooCommerce Subscriptions

So, when should you go all in with the WooCommerce Subscriptions plugin?

Choose it if:

  • You need advanced billing schedules (every 6 weeks, yearly with discounts)
  • You want to let customers pause or change their plans anytime
  • You sell digital products or memberships that require precise control
  • You want to offer free trials, upgrade paths, or coupons for recurring plans

This plugin is ideal for businesses that rely on subscriptions as part of their main revenue. It gives you a professional system with tons of options.

When to Use Native WooCommerce Renewals

Native Renewals are great when things are simple and you don’t need a deep feature set.

Use Native Renewals if:

  • You only offer one or two simple plans
  • You don’t want to buy extra plugins just yet
  • Your store is new and you’re still testing your business model

It’s a great way to get started with subscriptions without diving into heavy customization. You can always upgrade to WooCommerce Subscriptions later as your business grows.

What’s the Difference in How They Handle Payments?

Here’s where these two options really separate:

  • WooCommerce Subscriptions supports many gateways for auto-renewal: Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.Net, etc.
  • Native Renewals mainly rely on specific gateway integration like Stripe or WooPayments

This means if you’re using a lesser-known payment gateway, it might not support native renewals. But WooCommerce Subscriptions likely will.

Customer Experience: Who Wins?

Customer experience is HUGE when it comes to subscriptions. Imagine if a subscriber can’t update their billing info or pause a plan. That’s a customer ready to cancel.

WooCommerce Subscriptions wins here, hands down. It gives your users:

  • Account dashboard control over their subscriptions
  • Options to pause, cancel, or switch plans
  • Email notifications for every major event

Native Renewals is more basic. It’s designed to work in the background without giving too much control to customers.

What About Reporting and Admin Tools?

Managing subscriptions means tracking payments, renewals, and customer activity. With WooCommerce Subscriptions, you get a full admin dashboard showing:

  • Active and overdue subscriptions
  • Success and failed payment recovery
  • Churn rate reports and customer behavior

This is ideal for subscription-based businesses that want to measure their growth and improve operations.

With Native Renewals, the reporting is much more limited. You may need another plugin or manual tracking to get similar insights.

But What About Scalability?

Are you planning to grow? If so, start thinking ahead.

WooCommerce Subscriptions was built for scale. You can sell:

  • Dozens of products on separate or combined billing cycles
  • Group and bundle subscriptions for families or teams
  • Memberships that tie into digital services and gated content

If you’re building something long-term or preparing to launch something big, invest early in the right tools.

So… Which One Should YOU Use?

Here’s a quick cheat sheet:

Feature WooCommerce Subscriptions Native Renewals
Cost $$ (Paid Plugin) Free (core + supported gateway)
Customization Extensive Basic
Trial and Signup Fees Yes No
Automatic Emails Yes Limited
User Control Full Minimal
Scalability High Medium

Final Thoughts

If you want easy and free, start with Native Renewals. It’s beginner friendly and gets the job done for basic setups.

But if you’re serious about offering

To top